The story of Jephthah is either a great tragedy, or one of great absurdity. What do you take away from his life? What immediate lessons can we take away for ourselves and our church?
We cannot confuse gifting with growth. The life of Jephthah shows us how God raises a leader to do great work in his generation but at the end of his life, we also see something of his spiritual failure. We also see that the man God uses can be deeply flawed.
(A) One unlikely, but necessary, leader (Jdg 11:1-11)
We are introduced to Jephthah in Judges 11, and he is described as a Gileadite who was a mighty warrior, but was the son of a prostitute (Jdg 11:1). He was also driven out of the family by the other sons and therefore he had no inheritance (Jdg 11:2). His father was called Gilead, the name of the area too, and hence, we can infer that he was from a prominent family.
Indeed God seems to delight in choosing what is outcast and unacceptable in the world to shame the world.
In the previous chapter, in Judges 10:8, we also understand the setting. Gilead is also the shorthand for the tribes of Reuben, Gad and Manasseh.
Jephthah fled from his brothers and lived in the land of Tob, and worthless fellows collected around him and went out with him (Jdg 11:3). We have seen this phrase “worthless fellows” in the life of Abimelech (Jdg 9:4). who was also born of a concubine (Jdg 8:31). Thus, we are to think of Jephthah in similar terms as Abimelech, who was not a good leader.
War brought Jephthah back from the land of Tob (Jdg 11:4). In the closing verses of chapter 10, we have already been told that Israel faced the threat of the Ammonites (Jdg 10:18).
How does Jephthah respond to the elders of Gilead? He appeared to be bearing a grudge, slightly vindictive and bitter after all that had been done to him (Jdg 11:7). The elders did not seem to answer his question (Jdg 11:8). Like them, we often turn to what we think will save us in our needs but we also often misdiagnose our problems.
Yet when the people said that he could be their head if he was victorious over the Ammonites, he readily decided that he would fight for them (Jdg 11:9-11).
It is so easy to move from bitterness to power. And as a leader, his basic problem is that he hates these people. Hence, the book of Judges introduces another theme for us — who is qualified and fit to be the leader of Israel? What kind of leader does God’s people need? This is answered partially in Ruth and then in 1 Samuel.
God’s people elects a leader for themselves for the first time in the book where God is not consulted. Previously in Judges 3:9, 15, 4:6, 6:14, God raises a leader for them. This is foreshadowing, for there will be a king that is not raised by the Lord but given because the people wanted a king like the nations. This is the leader that Israel has after negotiating and bartering.
It is undeniable that God used Jephthah, but should he have bene the leader? Probably not. He did not really love the people and God was not involved in the process. How often do we appoint leaders on the basis of what we think we need and not based on God’s criteria? Do we choose pastors because they come from the right lineage, or because they are tall/handsome, their seminary training or how they perform behind the people? Do they have the heart of a shepherd?
(B) Two messages for diplomacy (Jdg 11:12-28)
Jephthah as appointed the head even though he had not won the battle (Jdg 11:11) and he sent messengers to the king of the Ammonites. He made ancestral claims on the land and also called it “my land” and saw it as an attack on him (Jdg 11:12).
The king of the Ammonites argued that Israel took it away from them and they are now seeking to restore it peaceably (Jdg 11:13).
Jephthah appeals to history, theology and empathy in his second diplomatic message. The king of the Ammonite claimed that Israel took the land from them. Jephthah argued that in the history of Israel, they were trying to get to their land and were not aggressive. Yet, when they attacked Israel, Israel merely fought back (Jdg 11:15-22, c.f. Num 20:14-21).
Regarding theology, notice how Jephthah also argued that God dispossessed people from the land (Jdg 11:23). Thus, God, a sovereign power greater than him, is the one who acted.
Finally, Jephthah also tried to persuade and find common ground. He argued that if their god gives them the land, they too, would have accepted it (Jdg 11:24).
So, what kind of leader is Jephthah from this speech? He is quite shrewd, thoughtful and was well-educated. He was trying not to immediately go to war, though he was a mighty warrior. He is indeed a complicated leader, and it is not easy to say clearly whether he is a good or bad leader. He is clearly gifted and also acted to work hard to solve the problem. Maybe he did not trust God and so much of his discussion so far has been checkered with both faith and foolishness.
So was he a good or bad leader? A good guy or a bad guy? The text is deliberately ambiguous. We are so eager to read the Bible and identify good and bad guys. We are also quick to sort people out in life and scrub out the “bad guys”.
(C) Three marks of spiritual failure (Jdg 11:29-12:7)
The Spirit of the LORD was upon Jephthah as he moves from place to place (Jdg 11:29). We have seen how the Spirit of the Lord has been mentioned in the lives of Othniel (Jdg 3:10) and Gideon (Jdg 6:34) and later in Samson (Jdg 13:25, 14:6, 19, 15:14). Men and women are empowered for a specific time and purpose, and not in perpetuity in the Old Testament. This is not the case for us in Christ, as after Pentecost, the Spirit is said to dwell in the believer in a permanent way.
However, this is not the focus.
Jephthah makes a rash vow in Judges 11:30-31. He did not know the Old Testament law, where burnt offerings are offered as a consecration and the objects are specific. Rather, he seems to practicing something of pagan religion, where he promises to give God whatever comes through the door if he is victorious. Jephthah’s actions seem transactional. God is never rewarded for blessing.
The battle ends and Jephthah is victorious and when he comes home, his daughter comes out to meet him with tambourines. However she was his only child (Jdg 11:34). He is now bound to sacrifice his daughter. She was given two months to weep for the fact that her life is cut short (Jdg 11:37). The text does not explicitly tell us she is killed but it is implied.
Now, the Old Testament is clear that God’s people are never to offer their children to pagan gods (c.f. Lev 5:4-5, Deut 12:29-31). This man does not know God’s law and character and yet, is bound in a legalistic vow to commit child sacrifice because he spoke rashly and now has to kill his daughter. He does not seem to know the God of grace and the law.
The text quickly moves on to another account in Judges 12:1-7, where Jephthah basically slaughters the men of Ephraim.
Jephthah is a tragic reminder that one can be raised by God, skilled in diplomacy, used by God to do great things and even be named in the hall of faith (Heb 11) and still be unfruitful in the ways that is described in 2 Peter 1:5-11. After reading Judges 11 and 2 Peter 1 together, we need to ask ourselves: Do we have virtue, knowledge, self-control, steadfastness, godliness etc? Let us prioritise our growth in Christ! Let us pray that we will be guarded in growing.